Businesses seeking to implement SAP Commissions, a robust sales commission management solution, have the option to utilize SAP's professional services or engage an external software implementation partner. 

Since 2008, Canidium has been implementing SAP Commissions. Our experience has shown that many businesses prefer to engage an external SI vendor for configuration advantages, even if they don't select Canidium.

This decision requires careful consideration of their specific needs, budgets, and timelines. In this article, we will weigh the pros and cons of each option to assist businesses in making informed choices.

SAP Commissions Professional Services

SAP offers professional services for Commissions directly as the developer of the solution. Below are some advantages and disadvantages of selecting this option:

Pros

Expertise: The professional services team at SAP is made up of experts who have a deep understanding of SAP Commissions. They are well-prepared to tackle complex challenges with great effectiveness.

Vendor-Specific Knowledge: The professional services team is knowledgeable about the product's capabilities, updates, and integrations with other SAP products, which ensures a smooth implementation process.

Product Support: Receiving prompt support and updates is likely with professional services. However, this is not exclusive to clients that choose their configuration services.

Cons

Cost: SAP's professional services often come at a premium cost, which may be a significant consideration for smaller or budget-conscious businesses.

Lack of Ongoing Support: Managed service contracts that facilitate training and support are not offered by SAP Professional Services but are highly common when working with a third-party vendor.

Software Implementation Partner

When you enlist the help of a software implementation partner, you'll be teaming up with a third-party vendor who specializes in SAP Commissions implementations. It's important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of this approach:

Pros

Tailored Solutions: A software implementation partner can offer personalized solutions that cater to the specific needs and complexities of a business's commission management process. This configuration allows for better alignment with existing workflows.

Cost Flexibility: Software implementation partners may provide various pricing models, allowing businesses to choose a plan that aligns with their budget and scalability requirements.

Industry-Specific Expertise: Some software implementation partners specialize in particular industries, enabling them to bring domain-specific knowledge to the table, leading to more tailored and efficient implementations.

End-to-End Support: Implementation partners often offer comprehensive support beyond the initial deployment, including training, maintenance, and updates, fostering long-term success.

Cons

Vendor Reliability: While reputable software implementation partners bring significant expertise, businesses must conduct thorough research to ensure the partner has a reliable track record, as choosing the wrong partner may lead to implementation delays or complications.

Read our article on 5 warning signs not to ignore in a potential SI partner

Integration Planning: Integration with other SAP products may require additional coordination and effort when working with a third-party implementation partner.

Communication and Collaboration: Effective communication and collaboration between the business and the implementation partner are vital for a successful implementation. A good SI partner will excel at this, but not every partner does.

Which sounds right for your organization?

When deciding between SAP Commissions professional services and a software implementation partner, there are several critical factors to consider, including budget, customization needs, industry-specific requirements, and timelines. 

While SAP's professional services offer extensive product expertise and seamless integration with other SAP products, they come at a higher cost. 

On the other hand, an external software implementation partner can provide tailored solutions and flexible pricing options, but selecting the right partner requires thorough research.

In order to make a wise decision, businesses need to thoroughly evaluate their needs and consider all the advantages and disadvantages. When it comes to implementing SAP Commissions, partnering with a software implementation specialist could be the best approach to achieve a successful implementation that meets the organization's specific needs.

Want to learn more about choosing the right SI partner? Check out these articles:

The Costly Truth: Why Hiring an SI Partner Beats In-House Configuration for SPM Software

3 Vital  Resources for SPM Implementation That You Might Not Have Considered

Software Implementation Partners: 5 Trust-Building Clues and 5 Alarm Bells You Shouldn't Ignore

Photo by Piret Ilver on Unsplash